31 October 2017


A bonnet that won’t latch, a grille that doesn’t clip in and panels that don’t fit.













These are among the quality and safety issues reported by a smash repairer who repaired a damaged car exactly as instructed by an insurer, with non-genuine parts.

Clay Hoberecht, owner of Best Body Shop in Wichita, Kansas in the United States, used the non-genuine radiator support, bonnet, bumper, headlight, grille and fenders specified by the insurer to repair a 2016 Ford Fusion (locally known as the Ford Mondeo).

In a Facebook video Hoberecht described the difficulty of fixing the front-end damage with non-genuine parts.

Watch the full video here:

“We said ‘we want OEM’. They [the insurer] said no.” said Hoberecht. “We said ‘we’ll build it your way’, and we’ll prove to you that this is not going to work.”

“The parts they want us to use are not likewise in quality, fit and performance

“The car has 20,000 miles on it. The body lines did not look like that when it came in.

“We are not willing to compromise our morals and bend the metal and make it fit.”























The process has also caused major inconvenience for the customer who is without the car while the poor repair is corrected.

Investigations in Australia by Genuine is Best previously exposed a potential risk for non-genuine bonnet safety latches to fail while driving.

When Hoberecht showed the insurer the inferior result from the non-genuine parts, he says the insurance representative provided him with a list of local repairers who, he was told, would have ‘zero problem making this fit’.

“There are a bunch of shops making this *expletive* metal work. That’s not ok with me,” Hoberecht said.

“If I had built this out of OEM parts in the first place this car would already be done… It is my goal to get a car in, get it repaired to pre-collision condition to be the safest and fastest we can within our skills.”

Will your insurer make sure your car is repaired to pre-collision condition?

Genuine Articles

Get Ready for the Road!
With COVID-19 restrictions being cautiously eased, you might be thinking about jumping back in the car after a few weeks, or months where it’s
Aren’t Genuine Parts Made by Other Suppliers?
A theme on Genuine is Best social media channels are comments stating: “You say only genuine parts are appropriate for each vehicle.  But, vehicle
Non-Genuine Parts Risking Chassis Safety
Testing by Federal Chamber of Automotive Industries (FCAI) initiative Genuine is Best has found non-genuine utility tray bodies can cause significant damage to the
Counterfeit Car Part Supplier Stopped
Federal Chamber of Automotive Industries (FCAI) member Toyota has stopped a major Australian vehicle body part and panel supplier from importing, advertising and selling
Hail Damaged? Read this now!
Was your car one of the estimated 10,000 damaged during the fierce January 20 hailstorm?
The 12 Checks of Christmas
We put a lot of pressure on ourselves over the Christmas period. Shops are packed, everybody wants to catch up and to-do lists can
Genuinely Safe – Parts Check
If you’re having your car serviced ahead of the holiday break, insist that your mechanic use genuine parts acquired through the authorised dealer network.
Clean the car – Interior Check
Yes, this is another safety critical check. No, it may not seem like it. A clean interior is a happy interior, but there’s more
Scroll to Top

Subscribe to get
our latest updates

We use cookies

We want to be Genuine with you. We use cookies to personalise content and ads, provide social media features and to analyse traffic. We will never share your personal information, but we may share data about your use of the site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners. (View Terms & Conditions)